Skip navigation menu
Mallory McMorrow for U.S. Senate

PRESS RELEASE

NYT: On Stevens: “While The Case For Her Candidacy Rests On Electability, It’s Far From Clear How Electable She Really Is”

“Stevens is not a particularly adept politician… Many of her views are out of step with both Democratic and independent voters in ways that could hurt turnout.”

MICHIGAN — Last night, the New York Times’ Michelle Goldberg published an opinion piece challenging the idea of Haley Stevens’ “electability,” on which the case for her candidacy rests, writing that her campaign and views are “out of step with both Democratic and independent voters in ways that could hurt turnout.” As Michiganders grow increasingly furious with the status quo and demand new leadership, Goldberg writes that Stevens is “a creature of the Democratic establishment at a moment when that establishment has never been more reviled.”

Excerpts of the piece are below:

Behind that chatter is the assumption that Stevens represents the Democratic Party’s best hope of holding a crucial Senate seat. But while the case for her candidacy rests on electability, it’s far from clear how electable she really is. Mainstream Democrats like Schumer have a theory about the kind of candidates who can win in purple states, but that theory might be outdated.

[...]

So all things being equal, an air of moderation is likely an advantage in purple states. But in Michigan, all things are not equal. Stevens is not a particularly adept politician. Many of her views are out of step with both Democratic and independent voters in ways that could hurt turnout. She’s a creature of the Democratic establishment at a moment when that establishment has never been more reviled.

[...]

Whatever your views on policy, however, it’s increasingly hard to argue that being pro-Israel is good politics. A February Gallup poll found that, for the first time since at least 2001, more Americans — including more political independents — sympathize with the Palestinians over the Israelis. In Michigan’s Senate primary, AIPAC is once again spending lavishly on Stevens’s behalf, but its support could become a liability, particularly in a state with the country’s highest share of Arab Americans. It’s not hard to imagine that some of the voters who declined to back Kamala Harris in 2024 because of the war in Gaza might also refuse to vote for Stevens.

[...]

“I have never seen this level of anger, frustration, discontent and anti-elite, anti-billionaire populist sentiment,” [Adam Carlson] said.

Stevens is on the wrong side of this sentiment in several ways. Unlike El-Sayed and McMorrow, she accepts money from corporate PACs, including those in the finance and insurance industries. While both of her opponents have released ambitious plans to regulate artificial intelligence, Stevens offers optimistic bromides about the technology.

[...]

It makes perfect sense for people who agree with Stevens about salient issues to vote for her. What makes less sense is the conviction that she’s uniquely well positioned to win in November. Michigan currently has six Democrats in the House. As the writer Matt Yglesias, usually a strong advocate of centrism, pointed out, in 2024 Stevens had the worst wins-above-replacement rating — a measure which uses partisan dynamics to compare candidates’ expected margin of victory to their actual performance — of any of them.

“I think moderation and policy positioning are incredibly important, but they’re not all that matters in politics and Stevens is literally a worse performer than Rashida Tlaib,” the left-wing congresswoman from Detroit, he wrote last year.

It’s perfectly understandable for mainstream Democrats watching this race to be anxious. I’m anxious. But when the electorate is this unhappy, it’s not necessarily safe to stick with the status quo.

###